Quantcast
 

True Confession — Can I Lie and Tell Her He Has an STI?

Wed, 11/19/2008 - 6:00am by DearSugar
1,383 Views - 64 comments

Weigh in and tell us if you forgive or not forgive this True Confession.

"I found out my boyfriend cheated on me. I know the girl's phone number and email address, so would I be forgiven if I were to tell her he has an STI, even though it's not true? I just want her to feel some sort of consequence, even if it's just until she gets tested."

Source

on Yahoo!

Related Dear Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

64 Comments Add a Comment

  • momma tikita's picture
    momma tikita
    1

    That depends...does the girl know he has a girlfriend? If so you can do what you please. If she has no idea this guy has another girl on his side then it's not her fault.
    I never liked women going after the "other" woman when she didn't even know she was the "other" woman!

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • GScott86's picture
    GScott86
    2

    I agree with momma, but then, if this b*tch has a boyfriend I'd go after him and tell her what a scum she is.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • bluesteyes's picture
    bluesteyes
    3

    For real? I would confront her instead of playing game. And the boyfriend, I would yell at him and possibly dump him. If I can't dump him, I would plan my way out already.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • missyd's picture
    missyd
    4

    I'd do it in a heartbeat. Wouldnt think twice.
    I'm a bit of a b*tch. LOL

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • Leene's picture
    Leene
    5

    No, you can't do that. Simple.

    I assume that girl KNEW the boy was taken, but if that is not the case - that girl is innocent. Your boyfriend really is the one you should be angry with. Or are you with someone so weak who only does what his under-section tells him to?

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • Swen's picture
    Swen
    6

    I don't think you should do this. Why not focus on your cheating boyfriend? He is the one who hurt you. You can't blame this woman for what your boyfriend did. It is your boyfriend's fault. Don't get involved with her. She doesn't matter. If it hadn't been her, your boyfriend could have found someone else.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • rosa tea's picture
    rosa tea
    7

    I think that would be really funny...everyone should get checked regularly anyway.

    BUT as the other commenters mentioned, it's really your man you should be angry at. Play your little trick and then leave the girl alone.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • skigurl's picture
    skigurl
    8

    the only reason i said not forgive is because it's too lame
    do something worse! i am all for making her squirm but this isn't that scary cuz within a couple days she'll know the truth and you'll look like a weird liar

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • skigurl's picture
    skigurl
    9

    oh, and i might be the minority here, but i LOVE when women go after the other woman! i am ALL ABOUT IT!

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • candace87's picture
    candace87
    10

    To be honest, you KNOW it would be wrong to do that. That's not to say it wouldn't be fun though Smiling. Although I don't think I could do this to someone, I would go more along the lines of "I won't say anything other than I think you should really get tested.. for EVERYTHING.. that's all I can say..." That would freak someone right out. But it would be MEAN!!

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • zabrow's picture
    zabrow
    11

    this will just make you look kind of pathetic. take the high road & just completely cut both of them out of your life. they don't deserve the time that it would take for you to plot some kind of revenge.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • omilawd's picture
    omilawd
    12

    UH, am I the only one here who thinks this is ridiculous and childish? I voted "not forgive" on the sole fact that it's so unnecessary.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • Hiding55's picture
    Hiding55
    13

    I voted "not forgive" too. You'll make yourself look silly and childish. I would tell her boy friend about it if she has one and definitely center more of your anger on YOUR boy friend.

    7 weeks 14 hours ago Report Comment
  • jules912's picture
    jules912
    14

    Yeah so it's not reeeally the right thing to do, but it's forgivable. Thing is, you can't tell if this girl knew he was cheating, in which case, she's going to be feeling pain for no reason known to her. He's the one you need to work it out with, and not necessarily by getting revenge, but by making him understand the pain you're undergoing. Revenge may seem sweet but don't be fooled, it soon comes back at you like a ton of bricks! x

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • LoveSarah's picture
    LoveSarah
    15

    I would do it. I would probably do a lot worse. I know it would be wrong, but oh well.
    So, I said forgive, I don't want to be a hypocrite or anything!

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • krae85's picture
    krae85
    16

    please don't waste your time! recognize this guy is a chump and forget him and your desire for revenge.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • aka Daria's picture
    aka Daria
    17

    this is the dumbest crap i have ever heard.
    go after the guy all you want but leave the other broad out of it.
    does not matter if she knew or not
    your bf at the time was the one who made the commitment to you, not her, he hurt you more than she did.

    don't be a twatwaffle.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • 356UIK's picture
    356UIK
    18

    I'd laugh my ass off when KARMA comes back and bites you even harder in the ass.

    Good luck Smiling

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • AlexE70's picture
    AlexE70
    19

    Not Forgive. Tell her he has an STI? To what end? Though any anger at her is understandable, your focus should be on your boyfriend. After all, HE is the one that cheated on you. So HE should be the one your anger is directed at. If you didn't know who the girl was, would you still be considering this idea? Revenge can be an intoxicating motivator, though I don't justify it in any way. Just remember who has really hurt you and betrayed your trust. And also, like 356UIK said, karma will get you in the end if you do, just like that show.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • jazzytummy's picture
    jazzytummy
    20

    What if you met some guy that you thought was great, hooked up with him, and out of the blue some girl called you to tell you he had an STI?

    I agree with others- dump the guy...he's the a$$hole here.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • Fushaa's picture
    Fushaa
    21

    I understand that you're upset but I think that's a bit childish. If she didn't know he had a girl then it's really not her fault and if she did know, well then hey, they deserve each other!

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • Ghana_Princess's picture
    Ghana_Princess
    22

    sure do it! she will find out later you were lying, tell ur boyfriend abt it who will tell mutual friends be4 u know everyone will know what you did and the focus will move from your cheat of a boyfriend and what a horrible thing he did to what a lil mischievous liar you r...

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • cjmara805's picture
    cjmara805
    24

    Don't drag the girl into this if she didn't know about you...

    unless she did. Then get your revenge!

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • TidalWave23's picture
    TidalWave23
    25

    Childish. Dump your boyfriend.

    He cheated? So maybe YOU should go out and get tested.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • Fallen85's picture
    Fallen85
    26

    I'm with skigurl on this one, I would want to do something worse. To both of them. If she knew about you, she deserves at least a little consequence... too bad you cant give her a real STI haha

    Your "man" deserves to be dragged behind your car with a sign saying "CHEATER" around his neck! ... but I think that might qualify as attempted murder so instead just dump him and tell him he has a tiny dick.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • runningesq's picture
    runningesq
    27

    Why are women so obsessed with getting back at "the other woman" when it is THEIR BOYFRIEND who cheated?

    Dump the loser and move on.

    7 weeks 13 hours ago Report Comment
  • bastylefilegirl's picture
    bastylefilegirl
    28

    You don't correct a wrong done to you by committing a wrong. First off what he did to you cheating on you is bad, but telling someone he had an STI and it getting passed that one person is much more heinous than him cheating on you. Okay he has ruined one relationship but by you telling that lie you have the potential to ruin most if not all of his future relationships. My suggestion to both you and your cheating boyfriend is to grow up you stop being vindictive, and he needs to keep his manhood in his pants!

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • CYL's picture
    CYL
    29

    This feels chidlish to me. Dump the guy, save the energy and go treat yourself to the spa Sticking out tongue Assholes are not worth wasting your anger over...

    And I agree with runningesq...your bf is the bigger *sshole here..

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • Indigo4320's picture
    Indigo4320
    30

    Not forgive.

    If you are still with the guy, dump him and move on. Not worth the time it takes to tell the lie.

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • geebers's picture
    geebers
    31

    Forgive - she should get tested anyway so you are doing her a favor.

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • ksindustryexec's picture
    ksindustryexec
    32

    ahhah wouldn't judge yah a bit.!!
    Thats hilarious.
    wouldn't do it myself, but wouldn't tell yah not to either way.

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • sonya ina's picture
    sonya ina
    33

    Why should he have to forgive YOU? He's the one who cheated. Get rid of hi stat.

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • AlexE70's picture
    AlexE70
    35

    Excellent point sonya ina. After all, HE is the one who cheated in the first place. Like I said before, I don't condone the whole "revenge" thing, but really, HE should be the one begging for forgiveness right now.

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • kandrew4's picture
    kandrew4
    36

    Really? REALLY?
    Even if she knew that you were in the picture, your boyfriend still had a choice in it. No, this does not mean that she was innocent, but shouldn't your issue be with your boyfriend? I don't even know why you'd still consider being with him. It might make you feel better to take your anger out on her, but she isn't your problem.

    Please have more self respect than that. Do NOT go after her; you don't need to give her anything to be able to use against you if you two have mutual friends. You were the one who was cheated on, but if you go crazy you make her look like a better person your boyfriend may have been retreating to. Do you want to come off that way?

    7 weeks 12 hours ago Report Comment
  • karlotta's picture
    karlotta
    39

    Women who let other women's boyfriends get in their pants should be set on fire and thrown off tall buildings.

    I hope you already dumped the mofo, because that's priority number 1. Priority number 2 is finding something way more humiliating to do to the b*tch (if she knew of your existence, of course. If not, she's just as much a victim as you are. And you should keep her informed that she's now doing a total douche.)

    7 weeks 11 hours ago Report Comment
  • ckeller825's picture
    ckeller825
    40

    I say forgive because I know your feelings are on a serious roller coaster ride. HOWEVER, don't attack the other girl. You should seriously beat your boyfriend down, and then bounce. Make him feel like scum.

    7 weeks 11 hours ago Report Comment
  • jacrabbit84's picture
    jacrabbit84
    41

    Well, if he cheated on you, he might!!! YOU better get tested.

    Oh, and...forgive.

    7 weeks 11 hours ago Report Comment
  • Marni7's picture
    Marni7
    42

    You dont even know if the girl had any idea he even had you in his life. So why dont u take all that built up anger and device an evil plan for your MAN, you know the one that actually directly betrayed you

    7 weeks 11 hours ago Report Comment
  • Jessiebanana's picture
    Jessiebanana
    43

    Not forgive, even if the woman knew he was taken she didn't owe you anything. It should be your ex bf you channel your anger at.

    Plus threatening somebody's health just seems tasteless regardless of the cause. Come out of this the classy one, not like some Jerry Springer trailer trash.

    Women really have got to stop this cattyness. It is so true when they say women hate women.

    7 weeks 10 hours ago Report Comment
  • Mykie7's picture
    Mykie7
    44

    Okay I've got to be honest.

    The politically correct answer is "No way, do NOT do that, it's wrong. Two wrongs don't make a right" etc etc.

    BUT

    This is something when I was in my early 20's and dating I might have done. It's just vindictive enough without causing long term damage. Obviously if she's tested she'll know it's a lie, and he can prove it is by being tested himself.

    BUT, remember too that Karma is a b***h and if you do something like this then be prepared for it to come back on you ten-fold.

    7 weeks 10 hours ago Report Comment
  • AlexE70's picture
    AlexE70
    45

    I agree with Marni7. Betrayal like that can drive you to do crazy things. But playing a serious prank like that on the OTHER woman isn't the way to go. But, nor is "beating down" the b/f. I understand the serious hurt involved, but violence is never a solution, regarless of the pain it's caused you.

    7 weeks 10 hours ago Report Comment